Going in you know that you’re in for a fantastic treat. You have excellent actors, superb direction, and a fascinating locale and story to be bedazzled by. And you’re not disappointed either. Scorsese meticulously constructs this new world for us and it feels extremely real. The actually island they shot this film on is off the coast of Boston and it’s one of the film’s best features. If they would’ve green-screened all of the external island shots it would have taken away from the film immensely. Luckily Scorsese is a true old school director and knows what it takes to weave a story.
Everyone asked me how I liked the film after I saw it, and I knew going in that many of my friends loved it, so responding to their question was interesting. I told them that I thought it was really good, but I didn’t love it, which I thought was a legit answer. And comparing it to other Scorsese films that I love, it probably wouldn’t be in the top 5 either.
The best things about the film I named already, however, I wasn’t as captivated by the story as I wanted to be. It felt semi cartoonish from time to time. Not in terms of legitimacy or realism, but in terms of pre-planned situations and straight story timelines. I felt like it was all a little too neat and tidy, I don’t know if that made sense, but it is an excellent film. Watch it with the lights off and with a big bowl of popcorn. Probably Scorsese’s most pronounced popcorn flick to date.
Rating: 8.5/10